Focus v. Flexibility

Published on: June 24th, 2014 by Hank Goldstein

At the recent Council on Foundations meeting in Washington DC I spent my time at the sessions beamed at family philanthropy. Most of the participants were from modest-sized, established family foundations with assets, I’d guess between $10 and $50 million.Thinking about how the learning might apply to the new and emerging family foundations  on which FFM/C mostly concentrates I came away with several sometimes contradictory ideas:

  • There was a lot of emphasis on focus – meaning the foundation’s core mission – assuming family members could agree  on what the focus should be. Generational differences; handing the reins to a new, younger generation; fear of “mission creep” as assets grew; staff changes and  more often than I expected, keeping younger family members engaged – and  more.
  • Concurrently an articulated concern that a fixed focus could interfere with flexibility  – meaning a receptivity to new ideas even within the focus area (I hope that makes sense). Moreover a few of the foundation trustees in attendance thought that for their foundations  it  might be time to re-assess mission, vision and multiyear direction.
  • Most of the foundations I encountered had small staffs – one or one and a half FTE staff, sometimes a family member doing the staff job. There’s  nothing  inherently wrong  in that except perhaps that the constraint may wet down new ideas.
  • It seemed to me that at least a few of the smaller foundations could or would be more efficiently managed as donor advised funds inside a community foundation. There are pluses and minuses to DAFs (meat for another blog) of course. The biggest drawbacks seem to be first the loss of autonomy, real or  implied; and second the lack of personal attention. For the donor with an asset base up to $10 million I would  not necessarily advise setting up a foundation. On the other hand I am now informally talking with someone who put deferred assets in one of the largest  nonprofit  community foundations. He would  like more attention paid than he’s getting. But I don’t think he’s really done the math on setting up a dedicated foundation. We’ll see.

In the end what is clear to me is how important it is to work very closely with the client in trying to discern the deep-down motivations; the ego needs; the family dynamic;

Comments are closed.

Return to Blog Page

Documents & Information

Contact Information

118 Wooster Street, Suite 2CD
New York, NY 10012

(212) 481 0149

Hank Goldstein

Disclaimers and Terms
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy

Add Us To Your Contacts

FFM/C qrCode

FFM/C Archives

Latest FFM/C Newsletter

Summer 2015

US giving totaled  more than $358 billion in 2014 according to Giving USA, long time compilers and publishers  together with the Center on Read more...

FFM/C Calendar

July 2024
« Jul